Uniform Civil Code: What is it? Why is it controversial?


What is Uniform Civil Code? What does Constitution say about it & why it’s such a controversial topic in India?

The concept of a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in India has been a subject of intense debate and discussion for several decades. The idea behind a UCC is to establish a common set of laws governing personal matters such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, and adoption for all citizens, regardless of their religious affiliations. Currently, India has different personal laws for different religious communities due to its diverse nature with multiple religions and religious laws.

What does Indian Constitutional says about Uniform Civil Code?

The Constitution of India, under Article 44, includes the provision for a Uniform Civil Code as one of the Directive Principles of State Policy. However, the implementation of a UCC is left to the discretion of the government, recognizing the sensitivity and complexity of the issue. Over the years, various governments have deliberated on the subject, but it remains a contentious and politically sensitive topic.

Examples of Different Civil Codes in India:

In India, personal laws that govern marriage, divorce, inheritance, and other related matters are derived from religious texts and customs. The major religious communities in India, such as Hindus, Muslims, Christians, and Sikhs, have their own distinct personal laws.

Hindu personal law

Hindu personal law is based on ancient religious texts and customs. The Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 governs marriage and divorce among Hindus, while the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 deals with inheritance. Under the Hindu Succession Act of 1956, Hindu women have equal rights to inherit property from their parents and have the same entitlement as Hindu men.

Muslims personal law

Muslims in India follow the Muslim Personal Law, which is based on the Shariah. The Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937 regulates matters related to marriage, divorce, inheritance, and maintenance among Muslims.

For Christians, Parsis, and Jews

For Christians, Parsis, and Jews, the Indian Succession Act of 1925 applies. Christian women receive a predetermined share based on the presence of children or other relatives, while Parsi widows receive an equal share as their children, with half of the child’s share going to the deceased’s parents if they are alive.

Why UCC is a controversial topic in India?

The debate surrounding the Uniform Civil Code in India is complex and often polarized. Proponents argue that a UCC would promote equality, eliminate discriminatory practices, and strengthen national integration. They believe it would ensure gender justice and women’s rights by creating a uniform set of laws.

However, opponents raise concerns about religious and cultural diversity, protection of minority rights, and potential political considerations. They argue that the imposition of a common civil code could erode cultural autonomy, impinge upon religious freedom, and dilute the unique rights enjoyed by minority communities.

Religious and Cultural Diversity: Upholding Plurality Amidst Calls for Uniformity

India’s rich tapestry of religious and cultural diversity has long been a defining characteristic of the nation. With multiple religions coexisting, each with its unique customs, traditions, and personal laws, the idea of implementing a Uniform Civil Code (UCC) has sparked intense debate.

Critics argue that a UCC would challenge this diversity by replacing individual religious laws with a single code applicable to all citizens. They contend that such a move could undermine the country’s cultural fabric and impinge upon citizens’ religious freedom.

Protecting Minority Rights: The Balancing Act of Preserving Identity and Autonomy

One of the primary concerns raised by opponents of the UCC centers around its potential impact on minority communities. Personal laws are intricately tied to the religious identity and practices of these communities.

Critics argue that imposing a uniform civil code may dilute the unique rights and protections enjoyed by minority groups and erode their cultural autonomy. In a pluralistic society like India, preserving minority rights and safeguarding their distinct practices is considered vital.

Political Maneuvering: The UCC as a Tool for Vote-Bank Politics

The UCC has frequently become a subject of political maneuvering and posturing. Political parties and leaders often exploit the issue to consolidate their vote banks or appeal to specific constituencies.

The sensitive nature of religious identity and the potential impact on minority communities have transformed it into a polarizing topic, with political calculations frequently overshadowing genuine discussions on the merits and drawbacks of a UCC.

Striving for Gender Equality: A Quest for Justice and Eliminating Discrimination

Advocates of the UCC argue that its implementation would promote gender equality and women’s rights by eliminating discriminatory practices present in some religious personal laws. They believe that a common code would ensure equal rights in areas such as marriage, divorce, inheritance, and maintenance.

However, opponents contend that gender justice can be achieved within the existing framework of personal laws, cautioning that a UCC might inadvertently infringe upon women’s rights protected under specific religious practices.

National Integration: Seeking Unity in Diverse Religious Communities

Many proponents of a common civil code argue that it would foster national integration by promoting a sense of unity among diverse religious communities and strengthening the secular fabric of the country. They believe that a UCC can serve as a unifying force. However, others acknowledge the highly complex and sensitive nature of the UCC issue, given the vast diversity of religious beliefs and customs across India.

In conclusion, the Uniform Civil Code remains a highly contentious and sensitive topic in India. Balancing the aspirations for equality, women’s rights, and national integration with the need to respect religious and cultural diversity is a complex challenge. It requires thoughtful deliberation, inclusivity, and an understanding of the potential impact on various communities. Ultimately, any discussion and decision regarding a Uniform Civil Code should aim to foster harmony, preserve individual rights, and uphold the principles of justice and equality for all citizens of India.

Thanks for reading from Storify News as a news publishing website from India. You are free to share this story via the various social media platforms and follow us on; FacebookTwitterGoogle NewsGooglePinterest etc.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe US

New York
clear sky
26.9 ° C
28.4 °
25.1 °
68 %
0 %
33 °
35 °
34 °
33 °
31 °


More like this

What did Nehru appeal to the people of India

Nehru's Vision: Inspiring India Towards Progress Do you know What...

NEET-UG 2024 counselling expected to start by July end, additional seats may be added: Report

The National Eligibility cum Entrance Test-Undergraduate (NEET-UG) 2024 counselling...

NEET-UG 2024: Counseling Postponed Amid Paper Leak Controversy; Awaiting New Date Announcement

The counselling process for NEET-UG 2024 has been postponed...

Decolonising Colonial Criminal Laws: India’s New Criminal Laws Introduced

By a comprehensive overhaul of the Indian Criminal Justice...